Just finished reading Sam Harris’ The Moral Landscape…not sure what to think. It’s a good book with a lot of neuroscience articles and research but it oversimplified the morality issue greatly. Even if a reader grants that we can map brain states that will reveal what maximizes human well-being, its still up to an individual to interpret what they find as good or bad. So while Harris may have a solid foundation for building a landscape for morals, his project only favors those who are willing to accept his criteria–which is far less than I think he realizes. I also think his so called “facts about the well-being of conscious creatures” is really a consequential point of view that doesn’t even begin to address all moral scenarios or circumstances that are going to permit certain segments of the population to make informed decisions. In principle, utilitarianism makes no real claim to resolve every circumstance since it’s based on what can be objectively known and not what is subjectively the case. If Harris view is correct, then all circumstances where people have hidden motives, reasons and principles are disregarded despite how maligned they are. In sum, this is really a problem to Harris argument because it posits one overly reductionistic standard as the norm for judging morality. I can hardly see how, in my brief superficial analysis, it would hold validity.

I will, however, give Harris the benefit of the doubt and say his book was fairly interesting. The studies and research supported his points very well. He also clarified his points on many occasions and used many rhetorical devices to convey his points with lucid prose. What’s more, the text and book layout was visually appealing and the writing flowed very well which pushed me to continue reading many a time even when I felt I couldn’t read another word. In this respect, the book is a gem, but I will let my previous points stand nevertheless.

 

 

Advertisements

About insightsofmind

Hello my name is Jerome and welcome to my blog. Here you will find various media and articles on assorted topics from around the world and some of my own personal interests. I’ve made this blog so you too can enjoy the topics and issues I examine and discuss in detail here. On occasion, I will only post bits and pieces for I am a busy guy. But when I get the time I always try to post as much material as possible. Now that you’re here take the time to look around and see if there’s anything that peaks your interest. Some material you will find will be pictures; others will be videos and articles. I’ve tried to offer a wide variety of mediums so that you the viewer can find the one that most suits you. And I hope with the time you’ve taken to at least read this you are already interested in what I have posted here. Thanks for your time.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s